Solved An important question for dear FreeBSD (about Cosmos WM) users.

Do you like my idea and what I do and offer?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1 12.5%
  • No

    Votes: 5 62.5%
  • I'll write my answer in the comments.

    Votes: 2 25.0%

  • Total voters
    8
My unprofessional take is:
a] it should be RAM efficient (XFCE levels max) - i3 should be OK
b] Global Menu is fine concept...but only on small monitors. Otherwise you have to travel to the very top even for small window at the bottom. On small monitors tiling is also wrong - better switch virtual desktop.
c] The real developer pain are all the other little utilities making the user happy.

I believe Ai age will make all this mostly obsolete soon. Programs and OS will not need Menus and buttons, at least not full stack of them but generated and positioned ad hoc, based on the workflow.

Mouse and keyboard will also take backseat. People are used to touch screens. And they will just touch buttons and turn dials or gesture (camera scanned) the dials Ai generated based on their voice prompt.
Thank you for sharing, I understand what you are talking about, and it will be better when next year you test BabaOS yourself and Zarya and I receive live feedback. So it will be better for everyone to have a dynamic OS, which makes sure that a person is happy with his computer, and rewrites the code of his OS as he needs, and as many times as he says, in order to achieve maximum coordinated work - computer hardware, human creativity, and Dawn. So as not to wait for hours for answers from technical support, and not to tinker with errors or requests yourself, and most importantly, not to pay for something that should be freely available at a basic level, like bread and milk on the table. And I hope AI will help us all with this. And thank you all so much for your feedback, I think I received enough information to draw some conclusions about my activities.
 
This is a question where the answer depends on the focus of attention, where the user is looking and whether the whole garden needs to be dug up, or whether he is happy with the state of affairs. I don't. Roughly speaking, I would like to see real progress in the age of AI and technical revolutions, and not something that you are fed with pieces from the table of large companies, year after year. That is, we don’t see a really cool OS, and if there is one, it is very, very expensive for a mere mortal, including the cost of his personal time, as is the case with Linux or BSD. I must admit that I also keep my own diary about technology and sometimes write down my thoughts about life in general. And one more thing: my OS is not only about FreeBSD, but also about web services. I’m the kind of person who wants to understand everything that’s happening, you know? For example, why do we have highly complex and sometimes outdated technologies that no one is in a hurry to develop? Every day I hear about iPhones, MacBooks, about how cool Apple is and how great it is at protecting our data and the ecology of the planet, but this does not make people happier, since not everyone is able to buy their products and make money from creativity. They should have provided all segments of society with their computers long ago, and done it at an affordable price, and not for thousands of dollars. And Windows wins here, their OS can be installed on any PC, but is it pleasant to use? Personally, I don’t, because in our age of AI, an operating system should be cool and one that impresses the user with its design and responsiveness, and not a closed garden for the elite.
Ordinary user is very unhappy with the state of affairs. He just needs to look at pictures and maybe read some new gossip. Email writing and presentation creating will certainly be on LLM. Some custom business app will better have just a few dials and a prompt window.

Well personal computers were getting cheaper every year. Even literal hobos have computers in their pocket. FOSS exists and will be even more plentiful garden thanks to Ai.
 
The greatest hurdle are drivers, tho. As it was and still is for Linux but even greater. Wm/desktop is just icing on the cake.
Then you have SW/apps. Linuxlator and of course our dear porters do some heavy lifting but still...
Listen, well, yes, it’s all about the drivers, but I also created my own package repository. And there I have already adapted many toys for my operating system, for example, the Neo Matrix Path, GTA WI CITY, but it is the closed nature of other OSes that hinders me, for example the API of the same Windows. Since if they were open, we would have long ago had a single OS running all programs and games in one place, it would be much more convenient than all these slow virtual machines and crutches like Wine and similar solutions. It is not possible to create a native Windows virtual machine, as with Linux, just in view of the closed doors of Windows, as is the case with MacOS. But I am sure that this would solve a lot of problems with the availability of our beloved BSD. But here Zarya comes onto the scene again, and she will help write high-quality analogues, and maybe even partially decompile them, these closed operating systems, so that it becomes possible to integrate their solutions. Since I know that Windows, for example, keeps many people in its prison only because of one advantage, these are games and drivers, the rest can be done perfectly well by Linux or FreeBSD. And they understand that Apple also has its own tricks up its sleeves, this is professional software that works only on their equipment. They understand that when AI reaches the peak of its growth and development, their digital prisons will come to an end. And I'm really looking forward to it.
 
Ordinary user is very unhappy with the state of affairs. He just needs to look at pictures and maybe read some new gossip. Email writing and presentation creating will certainly be on LLM. Some custom business app will better have just a few dials and a prompt window.

Well personal computers were getting cheaper every year. Even literal hobos have computers in their pocket. FOSS exists and will be even more plentiful garden thanks to Ai.
You're right.
 
Since I'm trying to convince my wife to create her a FreeBSD laptop to replace her MacBook, having some very MacOS looking like DE was not a bad idea per se.

Ya - my wife also regularly uses MacOS (and the "Mac ecosystem", aka: IPhone, etc). And I would also like to move my wife to FreeBSD some day as well.

At the moment I (DO NOT) think it's too heavy a lift to do that ... she was actually test using a FreeBSD account that I setup for her recently.

... But I am still wrestling with the Mac "Microsoft Office" products verses either Apache Open Office or Libre Office. I think (both) of these FreeBSD products are getting "a lot closer !" - but there might be a few more miles to go before they can completely replace Microsoft Office. (NOTE): She is not using using Microsoft cloud or AI products or anything at the moment that is "off box" Microsoft wise.

! Think Different !
 
Ya - my wife also regularly uses MacOS (and the "Mac ecosystem", aka: IPhone, etc). And I would also like to move my wife to FreeBSD some day as well.

At the moment I (DO NOT) think it's too heavy a lift to do that ... she was actually test using a FreeBSD account that I setup for her recently.

... But I am still wrestling with the Mac "Microsoft Office" products verses either Apache Open Office or Libre Office. I think (both) of these FreeBSD products are getting "a lot closer !" - but there might be a few more miles to go before they can completely replace Microsoft Office. (NOTE): She is not using using Microsoft cloud or AI products or anything at the moment that is "off box" Microsoft wise.

! Think Different !
For nerds, running FreeBSD is the source of pride.
Ladies, generally - not yours per se, want social proof of status (expensive shiny gadget) and familiarity (minimum of learning).

MS Office is becoming obsolete, fast. As are any office tools. It will be prompt box and few color dials on a screen showing results.
 
Below you can see the main large monitor, and below is a small one, that is, there are no problems with adaptability. It’s easy to drag and drop windows with the mouse, that is, they are completely controlled by the mouse; keyboard shortcuts are also available.

2026-11-10_18-10_1.png

2026-11-10_19-01.png
 
! Think Different !
That's exactly the point.
People see things just having another UI, or need to be used a tiny bit otherwise, even if it was easier, more efficient to use, delivers quicker and better results... doesn't matter, it just looks different is enough: End of story. Total refusal. They prefer to keep on whining and complaining about all the bad things those "evil companies" do to them, but change something? Use something else instead? That means learning something! Never, ever!

Plus the point with the application software:
Since I neither used MS Office a lot, nor using any Open- or LibreOffice unless it's an unavoidable must - I find the usage of those with their completely overkill bloated GUIs a most unefficient, illogical and weird imposition, a waste of time at the cost of my nerves; and in case of this wordprocessor junk even deliver worst results ever;that's no "text documents", that's garbage, pure garbage! ➡️🗑️ - to me it makes no difference at all which of them to use, they all make me 😤🤯🤬😫, only.
But there is all this "Teams" and "365" or any other online "cloud" stuff you need to join with a "client", which just cannot simply being replaced with some other open source software when the employer decided to use those.
Well, you could run those in a VM. But then you need to run an official, license payed Windows anyway. Where is the point in that? Except from having the rest of your machine securely separated from MS. But if there is nothing else?

Short: 💩
 
That's exactly the point.
People see things just having another UI, or need to be used a tiny bit otherwise, even if it was easier, more efficient to use, delivers quicker and better results... doesn't matter, it just looks different is enough: End of story. Total refusal. They prefer to keep on whining and complaining about all the bad things those "evil companies" do to them, but change something? Use something else instead? That means learning something! Never, ever!

Plus the point with the application software:
Since I neither used MS Office a lot, nor using any Open- or LibreOffice unless it's an unavoidable must - I find the usage of those with their completely overkill bloated GUIs a most unefficient, illogical and weird imposition, a waste of time at the cost of my nerves; and in case of this wordprocessor junk even deliver worst results ever;that's no "text documents", that's garbage, pure garbage! ➡️🗑️ - to me it makes no difference at all which of them to use, they all make me 😤🤯🤬😫, only.
But there is all this "Teams" and "365" or any other online "cloud" stuff you need to join with a "client", which just cannot simply being replaced with some other open source software when the employer decided to use those.
Well, you could run those in a VM. But then you need to run an official, license payed Windows anyway. Where is the point in that? Except from having the rest of your machine securely separated from MS. But if there is nothing else?

Short: 💩
They will all be replaced BabaOffice, since I make combines, for example, with assistive technologies, Zarya and I also write from scratch called the Reading Room, read downloaded texts, voice everything from the screen, and all this in a beautiful voice. Inside is a document scanner, printing, and many other things. We create specifically for people with special needs, autism, ADHD, who have poor vision, and (or) have other limitations.
 
Since I neither used MS Office a lot, nor using any Open- or LibreOffice unless it's an unavoidable must - I find the usage of those with their completely overkill bloated GUIs a most unefficient, illogical and weird imposition, a waste of time at the cost of my nerves; and in case of this wordprocessor junk even deliver worst results ever;that's no "text documents", that's garbage, pure garbage! ➡️🗑️ - to me it makes no difference at all which of them to use, they all make me 😤🤯🤬😫, only.

LOL - well I started out personal PC computing on a "Fat Mac" (ya the very early Macintosh that had 512 (Kilobytes) of total RAM memory) -- and Microsoft provided very usable and "Mac like" Word application on a 3+1/2 inch floppy disk back then. Did Microsoft HAVE to provide a Mac version of Word? Probably not -- Apple had "MacWrite" for text and WYSIWYG editing back in the day instead of Word.

So I (DO NOT) think Microsoft is completely evil... BUT -- (I also think) you have to pick and choose what products and services you are going to use from them.

My wife had ALWAYS used Microsoft products and nothing else until we met -- and then I switched her over to a Apple/Mac and... she's never looked back. Was it challenging to convince her to switch to Apple/Mac from MS/Windows ... well YES ! As you mentioned, the UI looks different -- I mean now you have to select File -> Print from the Apple bar menu to "Print something" and so forth.

Will it be a challenge to switch her to FreeBSD ? -- at the moment I don't think so.

The X11 UI for XFCE4 looks "really similar" to today's Mac UI interface -- and it runs a ton faster. The icons and menus largely work the same way. And even better -- those same UI elements (menus, icons, bars) will stay "the same" and not change every FreeBSD release cycle (mostly). Web surfing faster, apps loading and running faster, better networking and security, reliable backup and O/S maintenance, we are good to go !

Interestingly someone recently made an Apple MacOSX Snow Leopard "UI Clone" for FreeBSD. Maybe having an Apple Macintosh UI on a FreeBSD host is closer than it appears !?

(Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd): MacOS X Snow Leopard on FreeBSD
 
LOL - well I started out personal PC computing on a "Fat Mac" (ya the very early Macintosh that had 512 (Kilobytes) of total RAM memory) -- and Microsoft provided very usable and "Mac like" Word application on a 3+1/2 inch floppy disk back then. Did Microsoft HAVE to provide a Mac version of Word? Probably not -- Apple had "MacWrite" for text and WYSIWYG editing back in the day instead of Word.

So I (DO NOT) think Microsoft is completely evil... BUT -- (I also think) you have to pick and choose what products and services you are going to use from them.

My wife had ALWAYS used Microsoft products and nothing else until we met -- and then I switched her over to a Apple/Mac and... she's never looked back. Was it challenging to convince her to switch to Apple/Mac from MS/Windows ... well YES ! As you mentioned, the UI looks different -- I mean now you have to select File -> Print from the Apple bar menu to "Print something" and so forth.

Will it be a challenge to switch her to FreeBSD ? -- at the moment I don't think so.

The X11 UI for XFCE4 looks "really similar" to today's Mac UI interface -- and it runs a ton faster. The icons and menus largely work the same way. And even better -- those same UI elements (menus, icons, bars) will stay "the same" and not change every FreeBSD release cycle (mostly). Web surfing faster, apps loading and running faster, better networking and security, reliable backup and O/S maintenance, we are good to go !

Interestingly someone recently made an Apple MacOSX Snow Leopard "UI Clone" for FreeBSD. Maybe having an Apple Macintosh UI on a FreeBSD host is closer than it appears !?

(Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/freebsd): MacOS X Snow Leopard on FreeBSD
I don’t just have another clone, I’m completely writing the OS from scratch, taking existing FreeBSD developments as a basis, so as not to reinvent the wheel 20 times. And yes, you are right, I also think so, that not only the interface is close, but also a new kernel, new functions, and all this will work on many computers, and not just on those chosen by Apple. Microsoft, and this is purely my opinion, benefits from its closed nature, otherwise for a long time everyone used Linux, and only Linux. But in view of many closed parts of software, including hardware, we cannot even hope at the current moment in time that Linux or FreeBSD will win in this quiet digital software war. But still, the situation is much better than 5 years ago, because we are able to choose hardware for our operating system, and not vice versa. And I hope that next we will learn to print boards and most of the hardware for our favorite OS, bypassing existing restrictions from corporations.
 
Please write who has used Thinkpad laptops? Here’s the thing, I’m still testing the mobile version of BabaOS on a VM, and I heard on these laptops from Lenovo there are built-in modems for SIM cards. Are they workers? That is, it’s like inserting a SIM into a smartphone and the modem accepts AT commands? I have not yet found mobile equipment that is cheap and supports all sorts of Linux, but netbooks and laptops are another class of devices, also mobile, but you can’t put them in your pocket.
 
Yes, I want to make a dialer so that I can make free calls within my ecosystem. I think such opportunities are relevant not only for me; instead of depending on mobile operators, I will only need the Internet. Zarya and I have already prepared the necessary software for this, but my gaps in the hardware, if there are those here who can tell me how best to do testing, since not all things are visible on a VM, it is better if these are conditions close to real ones, on real mobile hardware that fits in a pocket. There is also a Raspberry Pi, but it takes a long time for me to get the components. And there are no problems with printing clothes, the problem is how best to test our software in advance in order to decide on the final mobile hardware that will fit in your pocket.
 
That is, it’s like inserting a SIM into a smartphone and the modem accepts AT commands?
Nothing specific but I've been curious about that; seen plenty of Dell laptops (and 1 HP) with WWAN and SIM slots, but never a WWAN card 😅

I wonder if it's possible to put Qualcomm phones (EDL) into a modem mode and present over USB like a USB modem to computers? Could maybe be used to simulate a WWAN card and ModemManager handling, but with a Android phone.
 
I don’t just have another clone, I’m completely writing the OS from scratch, taking existing FreeBSD developments as a basis, so as not to reinvent the wheel 20 times. And yes, you are right, I also think so, that not only the interface is close, but also a new kernel, new functions, and all this will work on many computers, and not just on those chosen by Apple.

I am fine with something that "Looks like a Mac", "Quacks like a Mac" .. is it a Mac?, FreeBSD? or a duck? We really don't know :-). But something that is FreeBSD and runs really well and has a Mac like look and feel is pretty cool ! There have been more than a few people that have tried copying the Mac hardware and UI interface this over the years. As you saw above someone copied the Apple Snow Leopard UI interface and made it run on FreeBSD.

There were actually a few Apple "clone" computers manufactured back in the day (1990s era) made by various vendors -- I remember (A LOT) of Apple legal and law suit stuff going on back then. The "very heavy handed" Apple law suits put a "chill" on the Mac clone market back then and quite a few of those vendors went out of business. You can read more about this here: (Link: Wikipedia): Macintosh clone

Apple made the jump from "Mac Finder" based OS/s to !! IT'S REALLY UNIX !! around 2001 when they switched over to a "Next Step" derived MacOS from the "Next" machine hardware. You will likely be more successfully if you embrace what Apple did and go with --> !! IT'S REALLY UNIX !! <-- in some way that hides the UNIX parts and uses a great UI interface. (Link: Wikipedia): macOS

Apple is not shy about saying they used FREEBSD in MacOS: From the (Wikipedia article): "macOS (previously OS X and originally Mac OS X) is a proprietary Unix operating system, derived from OPENSTEP for Mach and FreeBSD, which has been marketed and developed by Apple since 2001.

Apple skinned the IPhone, AppleTV, Macs, (everything else MacOS, IOS, etc) to run "UNIX" and that has been highly successful and profitable for them. UNIX was the real O/S winner in the end - and no knows that :-). Does anyone still have a "Windows Phone"?
 
Back
Top