Solved An important question for dear FreeBSD (about Cosmos WM) users.

Do you like my idea and what I do and offer?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1 12.5%
  • No

    Votes: 5 62.5%
  • I'll write my answer in the comments.

    Votes: 2 25.0%

  • Total voters
    8
I'm developing my desktop manager. And I want to know your opinion, that is, do you need such a manager? I’m inspired by MAC OS X 10.6.8, but not a copy-paste, but one that would be convenient to use myself. Take the i3 manager as a basis; now the Dock and Panel are already working, there are settings and a global menu, as well as a tray and programs included in Cosmos WM. I can’t show screenshots yet, as well as video screenshots, but I’m writing one for my manager as part of the BabaOS project based on our favorite distribution. I’m not developing it alone, together with Zarya, she’s my assistant, and yes, she’s an AI. I’m not a vibe coder; I’ve been working on OS for a long time, long before the advent of AI. Here I just want to get feedback, because I have big plans for BabaOS and I want to make it a truly free distribution, and so that it is as convenient and comfortable to use as MAC OS X 10.6.8 once was, and I hope you will support me and not peck me or throw tomatoes at me. Well, no one needs this and in general, why reinvent wheels. From the working parts, I’ll say that I’m currently writing from Cosmos WM and there are beautiful orange windows, convenient virtual tables, a Dock and a tray with a global menu. And also an orange or tangerine, instead of a bitten apple. The Dock supports multi-monitors, we have also improved all the code and the code of BabaOS itself, and worked on the sound system to make it holistic. The only problems I encountered were bluetooth wireless networks. We abandoned Wayland in favor of X and are developing our own UI called Aqua. I think I’ll finish it by the end of this year, I’ve been working on it for almost a year, but I’ve been thinking for a long time about making my own distribution based on BSD. And we also have our own repository, it is located in Russia. Here, in addition to free and official software, closed programs with non-free code are also available as demos for review and possible future purchase of these programs. This is like a demonstration of what FreeBSD is capable of in real conditions, and why the owners of this distribution will not make a really better OS than, for example, the commercial and closed OS from Apple. So that it would be really convenient for people to use it on all computers, and not just on expensive toys like macbook and macmini, and others. Again, I’m only curious about your opinion on this matter, but I’m doing the distribution primarily for myself, because I’m tired of the eternal framework, rules, boundaries of all kinds of Apple. And I really want a distribution that can be installed on any computer, and not less convenient and beautiful than macOS. And Zarya and I almost put things in order in the so-called hidden files in the home directory, so that it would be aesthetic without a zoo. To do this, we rebuilt the entire FreeBSD distribution in order to create our own BabaOS. In general, yes, we are making a free MAC OS X 10.6.8, only a modern one with hardware support, a browser, and other programs. And we are working on the virtual stack, that is, Wine and other virtual machines (qemu for example), combining them into one virtual machine. So that our OS can easily run software from other OSes as if they were its own. Now I just need your little encouragement that I'm not alone. In any case, thanks to everyone who writes and gives feedback.
 
I'm developing my desktop manager. And I want to know your opinion, that is, do you need such a manager? I’m inspired by MAC OS X 10.6.8, but not a copy-paste, but one that would be convenient to use myself. Take the i3 manager as a basis; now the Dock and Panel are already working, there are settings and a global menu, as well as a tray and programs included in Cosmos WM. I can’t show screenshots yet, as well as video screenshots, but I’m writing one for my manager as part of the BabaOS project based on our favorite distribution. I’m not developing it alone, together with Zarya, she’s my assistant, and yes, she’s an AI. I’m not a vibe coder; I’ve been working on OS for a long time, long before the advent of AI. Here I just want to get feedback, because I have big plans for BabaOS and I want to make it a truly free distribution, and so that it is as convenient and comfortable to use as MAC OS X 10.6.8 once was, and I hope you will support me and not peck me or throw tomatoes at me. Well, no one needs this and in general, why reinvent wheels. From the working parts, I’ll say that I’m currently writing from Cosmos WM and there are beautiful orange windows, convenient virtual tables, a Dock and a tray with a global menu. And also an orange or tangerine, instead of a bitten apple. The Dock supports multi-monitors, we have also improved all the code and the code of BabaOS itself, and worked on the sound system to make it holistic. The only problems I encountered were bluetooth wireless networks. We abandoned Wayland in favor of X and are developing our own UI called Aqua. I think I’ll finish it by the end of this year, I’ve been working on it for almost a year, but I’ve been thinking for a long time about making my own distribution based on BSD. And we also have our own repository, it is located in Russia. Here, in addition to free and official software, closed programs with non-free code are also available as demos for review and possible future purchase of these programs. This is like a demonstration of what FreeBSD is capable of in real conditions, and why the owners of this distribution will not make a really better OS than, for example, the commercial and closed OS from Apple. So that it would be really convenient for people to use it on all computers, and not just on expensive toys like macbook and macmini, and others. Again, I’m only curious about your opinion on this matter, but I’m doing the distribution primarily for myself, because I’m tired of the eternal framework, rules, boundaries of all kinds of Apple. And I really want a distribution that can be installed on any computer, and not less convenient and beautiful than macOS. And Zarya and I almost put things in order in the so-called hidden files in the home directory, so that it would be aesthetic without a zoo. To do this, we rebuilt the entire FreeBSD distribution in order to create our own BabaOS. In general, yes, we are making a free MAC OS X 10.6.8, only a modern one with hardware support, a browser, and other programs. And we are working on the virtual stack, that is, Wine and other virtual machines (qemu for example), combining them into one virtual machine. So that our OS can easily run software from other OSes as if they were its own. Now I just need your little encouragement that I'm not alone. In any case, thanks to everyone who writes and gives feedback.
Have you seen Gershwin Desktop yet? It sounds like we share a lot of ideas.
 
I don't like "distributions", I don't like Apple, and I don't like modern desktops. It's all just cosmetics that don't really change much in the end. I've been saying this jokingly for a long time, but it's going to become a reality soon: there will be as many desktops as distributions as users and not enough letters in the alphabet to name them all. One of the qualities required for a technician is adaptability, when you find something that suits you 80%, you work with it, because 100% is impossible; it's a never-ending quest. Don't anyone tell me with my mindset, we'll never progress. I use modern tools when they actually bring something to the table (text editors, AI, coding agents, C++23, ...).
 
Since I'm trying to convince my wife to create her a FreeBSD laptop to replace her MacBook, having some very MacOS looking like DE was not a bad idea per se. But I will neither join that project, nor will I have a use for anything not fully functioning reliably but being some half finished idea, only.

Personally I neither have no use for nor interest in such a thing. But that's just only me I can talk for.
I don't want to discourage nobody, since if somebody starts on something there are always for sure others having also a use for it, too.

In general I always applaud everything new comes optional, so enriches the menu everybody can pick freely from and decides for her-/himself if use it or not.
Demanding something to become by default part of the base system, e.g. the periodically again turning up idea of FreeBSD must come by default with an autoinstalling WM/DE, is something entirely else, and you'd see me on the barricades instantly. But this ain't the case here.

Apart from that, I always remind of the question, if something is worth the effort.
Is the amount of work needed to realize such a project estimated right? Is there a real chance to get it into a mature release state in a reasonable time? Or is there a danger somebody underestimated the resources for such a project, and perhaps get lost on the open ocean? Which then could be seen as wasted time and effort, maybe better had been put into something else instead, something already exiting. There are always more ideas than resources to realize them. That's why so many open source projects including WMs and DEs always lack of development force power, and not a few ones never got beyond some practically unusable carcass. Or maybe perhaps it's less effort to become friends with and learn and configure what there already is instead of starting the 415th sideshow?

However,
in any case it's your decision, and your very own decision, only, what you do.
You have your thoughts, ideas, and reasons why you think to start such a thing. But you asked in advance, and here you got my very own personal opinion, with what you are totally free to do what you like: ➡️🗑️:cool:
In any case it will teach you a lot of things, and will be fun to do so.
So, if you start on it, I wish you success.
 
You are either running BSD or you are not. There are no "distros". That's a Linux term describing a completely different method of creating different operating systems. You are creating a desktop environment, not a new operating system "based on" BSD.
Yes, I understand that, for integrity I chose BSD and not Linux. But I have ideas, and many have already been implemented, far beyond the boundaries of Cosmos WM. Given that there are already tens of thousands of different distributions based on the Linux kernel and GNU utilities, I personally don’t like this approach, because I vote for the Unix philosophy, where one tool performs one task, but does it efficiently. And if I suggest my friend try Linux, he will twirl his finger at his temple, because it is really difficult to choose, as well as install and configure. And in the case of BabaOS and FreeBSD itself, everything is as simple as possible, but there is a real lack of high-quality desktop and software specifically for ordinary computers.
 
Since I'm trying to convince my wife to create her a FreeBSD laptop to replace her MacBook, having some very MacOS looking like DE was not a bad idea per se. But I will neither join that project, nor will I have a use for anything not fully functioning reliably but being some half finished idea, only.

Personally I neither have no use for nor interest in such a thing. But that's just only me I can talk for.
I don't want to discourage nobody, since if somebody starts on something there are always for sure others having also a use for it, too.

In general I always applaud everything new comes optional, so enriches the menu everybody can pick freely from and decides for her-/himself if use it or not.
Demanding something to become by default part of the base system, e.g. the periodically again turning up idea of FreeBSD must come by default with an autoinstalling WM/DE, is something entirely else, and you'd see me on the barricades instantly. But this ain't the case here.

Apart from that, I always remind of the question, if something is worth the effort.
Is the amount of work needed to realize such a project estimated right? Is there a real chance to get it into a mature release state in a reasonable time? Or is there a danger somebody underestimated the resources for such a project, and perhaps get lost on the open ocean? Which then could be seen as wasted time and effort, maybe better had been put into something else instead, something already exiting. There are always more ideas than resources to realize them. That's why so many open source projects including WMs and DEs always lack of development force power, and not a few ones never got beyond some practically unusable carcass. Or maybe perhaps it's less effort to become friends with and learn and configure what there already is instead of starting the 415th sideshow?

However,
in any case it's your decision, and your very own decision, only, what you do.
You have your thoughts, ideas, and reasons why you think to start such a thing. But you asked in advance, and here you got my very own personal opinion, with what you are totally free to do what you like: ➡️🗑️:cool:
In any case it will teach you a lot of things, and will be fun to do so.
So, if you start on it, I wish you success.
Thank you. And I’m glad that you gave me a little feedback, it was useful and very useful for me, thank you again. Yes, of course I understand your words, and completely agree with you, but I’ve been with FreeBSD for a long time so that I can soberly assess my strengths. Just this year alone, Zarya and I completely redesigned the i3 window manager to make it a full-fledged Dock, Panel, Menu (orange or tangerine) (together with a launchpad, the so-called kiosk mode), then we created Pulse, which is a resource monitoring along with cool things that calculate the energy of processes and your electricity costs (depending on the region, prices vary by kilowatts everywhere) (we also implemented reading other people’s resources, for example from the server directly into Pulse) (that is, one software does one thing, and does it well), we have our own Notes, our own shared clipboard between devices, Spaces (virtual tables, each name is taken from my Russian culture, fairy tales, folk stories), Zarya is an AI that is built into the OS itself, you choose a supplier (paid or free), pay if necessary and it works with you doing a variety of things, using self-learning. Everything has been built and is planned to be built on QT for now, then we will gradually move on to our Aqua (water UI), and the BabaFM file manager can already do a lot of things that Apple’s Finder can do. And even more, because I want to see my OS in such a way that I myself would be comfortable using it. We place a special emphasis on assistive technologies, you know, for special people (poor vision, autistic people, ADHD and the like who have difficulties working on a computer), in addition, there is a Luna browser based on chromium, Zarya is also built into it and it has support for assistive technologies that we are developing for BabaOS. I don’t want to offend anyone, but these Gnome and KDE are crude, and it’s impossible to use them, I tried so many times myself. Regarding the assessment of forces, I think by 2027 my axis will be completely ready. Well, it can already do a lot, I just have to finish the Installer (and those same convenient packages as in macOS) (and the installer of the OS itself), and the disk utility. Other things already work, such as BabaConsole (working with the terminal), viewing pictures, videos, downloading torrents, a translator, downloading from YouTube, and other things available from the user’s GUI. There’s only one thing, but we won’t have X’s and O’s, like in macOS open close windows (traffic lights), because we have orange windows that the OS itself controls. I rely on Zarya as an assistant, and on an intuitive and fast responsive UI where the mouse and keyboard control the work, but the person himself, using gestures, for example, Zarya. But most importantly, the code should be open and accessible to everyone. Here I continue to doubt my choice, but it’s still better when you can open the code, fix the things you need, compile and install it into the system. I think Zarya will do all this, heal and renew herself in the future.
 
I don't like "distributions", I don't like Apple, and I don't like modern desktops. It's all just cosmetics that don't really change much in the end. I've been saying this jokingly for a long time, but it's going to become a reality soon: there will be as many desktops as distributions as users and not enough letters in the alphabet to name them all. One of the qualities required for a technician is adaptability, when you find something that suits you 80%, you work with it, because 100% is impossible; it's a never-ending quest. Don't anyone tell me with my mindset, we'll never progress. I use modern tools when they actually bring something to the table (text editors, AI, coding agents, C++23, ...).
BabaOS is more than cosmetics, it is a philosophy, and these are tools that I also write for myself and for my life. Since I’ve long been tired of Apple’s solutions, of Ubuntu’s solutions (when they abandoned Gnome 2 and switched to Unity), and I just want to work and be creative in a quiet mode. And do not depend on other people’s decisions, on subscriptions, on clouds, for example. Thanks for the feedback. We just need to keep what we all already have and it works the way we expect it to.
 
Have you seen Gershwin Desktop yet? It sounds like we share a lot of ideas.
Yes, but only with a global menu (which I have already implemented) and Application Bundles (this part has not yet been implemented), otherwise it is a regular desktop. I think my OS is much more beautiful and convenient, since I offer many more tools and capabilities.
 
BabaOS is more than cosmetics, it is a philosophy, and these are tools that I also write for myself and for my life. Since I’ve long been tired of Apple’s solutions, of Ubuntu’s solutions (when they abandoned Gnome 2 and switched to Unity), and I just want to work and be creative in a quiet mode. And do not depend on other people’s decisions, on subscriptions, on clouds, for example. Thanks for the feedback. We just need to keep what we all already have and it works the way we expect it to.
This also sounds like me and exactly the kind of thing I rant about all the time lol. Well sounds like we will have our own opinionated forks. Which is great. It’s total freedom. There is no need to come together when AI can build whatever we want. We have our teams already.
 
Yes, but only with a global menu (which I have already implemented) and Application Bundles (this part has not yet been implemented), otherwise it is a regular desktop. I think my OS is much more beautiful and convenient, since I offer many more tools and capabilities.
Hey if you build something really good maybe I’d be happy to be lazy and just play World of Warcraft. But also keep in mind while we do these things a million other people can do the same things. It’s going to be hard to be special.
 
My unprofessional take is:
a] it should be RAM efficient (XFCE levels max) - i3 should be OK
b] Global Menu is fine concept...but only on small monitors. Otherwise you have to travel to the very top even for small window at the bottom. On small monitors tiling is also wrong - better switch virtual desktop.
c] The real developer pain are all the other little utilities making the user happy.

I believe Ai age will make all this mostly obsolete soon. Programs and OS will not need Menus and buttons, at least not full stack of them but generated and positioned ad hoc, based on the workflow.

Mouse and keyboard will also take backseat. People are used to touch screens. And they will just touch buttons and turn dials or gesture (camera scanned) the dials Ai generated based on their voice prompt.
 
Are you really sure that a lying slop machine brings anything to the table? I mean from what I've heard they make you think you are faster, but you actually code slower. Here's something from a blog I frequent: AI coders think they’re 20% faster — but they’re actually 19% slower
It is a year old study. It improved quite a bit. Sure, if someone wants production ready Minecraft, that is a lot of mistakes. But people are using it and have results. Sure it is more of Ai assisted than vibecoded but I heard several dudes with active projects saying it saved them months as they can compare. But they also say, you need to assemble it by small pieces.
One problem I see reported is that people start a lot projects, they wouldn't dare to without Ai and it bogs them down eventually. Like when you rent an excabator and suddenly you can dig up the whole garden - but should you?
 
Are you really sure that a lying slop machine brings anything to the table? I mean from what I've heard they make you think you are faster, but you actually code slower. Here's something from a blog I frequent: AI coders think they’re 20% faster — but they’re actually 19% slower
What we have now isn't like chatgpt 2022 era. I made KMS for virtio-gpu work on arm64 in 1 day. I made rpi500+ boot natively (not UEFI that isn't supported by my model) in 1 day. Those are real results.

However the effectiveness depends on how knowledgable the person driving it is how much background they have in how things work, they must know how to direct, and what said code is doing.

That said and what I was trying to say above. Right now I don't think it matters how good it is, because what's going to happen is there will be 1 million tiny projects that get no attention no matter how much more they have to offer, because there two many people doing their own things, too many to pick from, and then there will be established projects like FreeBSD. It's just like there were always thousands of 1-person Linux distributions and only a few get significant amounts of users. I already see this happening in real time, it's kind of cool, but these cannot be FreeBSD replacements, and lets face it KDE isn't going to get overtaken either. That goes for even my hobby projects.

Established projects like FreeBSD will still get more attention of course because they have teams responsible for security fixes, they have teams in general. There is less likelihood for breaches, or data loss from a true project vs a one person project. For 1 person projects, they should be careful for that reason as well how far they go with things. The reason is just because a project is open source does not make them immune to lawsuits for data loss, breaches, or infringement. Without a foundation (which you need more than 1 person for), or an LLC (which involves spending a fair amount of time and money to establish) there is no protection at all. There is no firewall for personal assets without something like one of those in place for anyone who distributes software. A great license alone is not a 100% guarantee of no risk especially without those.
 
What we have now isn't like chatgpt 2022 era. I made KMS for virtio-gpu work on arm64 in 1 day. I made rpi500+ boot natively (not UEFI that isn't supported by my model) in 1 day. Those are real results.

However the effectiveness depends on how knowledgable the person driving it is how much background they have in how things work, they must know how to direct, and what said code is doing.

That said and what I was trying to say above. Right now I don't think it matters how good it is, because what's going to happen is there will be 1 million tiny projects that get no attention no matter how much more they have to offer, because there two many people doing their own things, too many to pick from, and then there will be established projects like FreeBSD. It's just like there were always thousands of 1-person Linux distributions and only a few get significant amounts of users. I already see this happening in real time, it's kind of cool, but these cannot be FreeBSD replacements, and lets face it KDE isn't going to get overtaken either. That goes for even my hobby projects.

Established projects like FreeBSD will still get more attention of course because they have teams responsible for security fixes, they have teams in general. There is less likelihood for breaches, or data loss from a true project vs a one person project. For 1 person projects, they should be careful for that reason as well how far they go with things. The reason is just because a project is open source does not make them immune to lawsuits for data loss, breaches, or infringement. Without a foundation (which you need more than 1 person for), or an LLC (which involves spending a fair amount of time and money to establish) there is no protection at all. There is no firewall for personal assets without something like one of those in place for anyone who distributes software. A great license alone is not a 100% guarantee of no risk especially without those.
True.
Just a thought or two, tho....
a] It will be also possible to program your own app without publishing anything OR Ai review the existing ones (by yourself or some very cheap certification server). Before, one person projects were mostly avoided for the reasons you mentioned - security reasons, mainly. If Ai can check it or do security fixes, why not use it.
b] Maybe we are too stuck in settled ways. Maybe what I mentioned in a] will also mean total revamp of the not only apps stack but OS landscape too. How fast is hard to judge. We have Unix for half a century. UI like KDE will certainly take a hit first.

And as funny note. Establishing LLC is the only reason I would rent Grokbot etc. It can guide me through it, if not cough up the cash needed :D
 
Jesus Christ. Another Linux refuge flooding the forums with this type of bulls**t. Why not just use vanilla FreeBSD to your liking and go on about your day.

Understand something; FreeBSD is a base operating system; a concept that is non-existent with the GNU/Linux split dichotomy. It's incredibly difficult to fork and maintain a separate, complete operating system. You will likely burn out and abandon your project.

Just use FreeBSD.
 
True.
Just a thought or two, tho....
a] It will be also possible to program your own app without publishing anything OR Ai review the existing ones (by yourself or some very cheap certification server). Before, one person projects were mostly avoided for the reasons you mentioned - security reasons, mainly. If Ai can check it or do security fixes, why not use it.
b] Maybe we are too stuck in settled ways. Maybe what I mentioned in a] will also mean total revamp of the not only apps stack but OS landscape too. How fast is hard to judge. We have Unix for half a century. UI like KDE will certainly take a hit first.

And as funny note. Establishing LLC is the only reason I would rent Grokbot etc. It can guide me through it, if not cough up the cash needed :D
It’s just hard to get the engagement, spotlight or recognition and it’s going to get harder now. It is not any matter of difficulty. Almost nothing is difficult anymore. My forums are empty. These forums where almost everyone is rude are not empty lol.
 
It’s just hard to get the engagement, spotlight or recognition and it’s going to get harder now. It is not any matter of difficulty. Almost nothing is difficult anymore. My forums are empty. These forums where almost everyone is rude are not empty lol.
It was always like that (hard to get traction) before Internets...plus difficult to create something useful i.e. something what people give a F about (real measure of value).
To get on the radio or TV you needed a lot of luck, a lot of very good work and/or marketing money or good old nepotism (see Hollywood).

Now it is returning to the default but for a reason of inflation of realized ideas. But I believe something really useful will still find it's way through the fog.

Legacy desktop is probably not that, tho, sorry OP. At least not for long.
 
It was always like that (hard to get traction) before Internets...plus difficult to create something useful i.e. something what people give a F about (real measure of value).
To get on the radio or TV you needed a lot of luck, a lot of very good work and/or marketing money or good old nepotism (see Hollywood).

Now it is returning to the default but for a reason of inflation of realized ideas. But I believe something really useful will still find it's way through the fog.

Legacy desktop is probably not that, tho, sorry OP. At least not for long.
This is not about the usefulness of a product, thing, person, but about its availability. You know, in order for me to buy a computer from Apple with their operating system, I need to spend at least 30 thousand rubles for hardware that costs a maximum of 15 thousand, that is, pay two and a half times for hardware that is already at least 5 years old. For this money I could build a good powerful gaming PC, or a graphics workstation, or buy a game console. But unfortunately, it is not possible for an ordinary person who does not understand computers to work with Windows or Linux; for this, you need to pay too much time to understand which distribution to choose, or how to configure Windows correctly, or suffer with its errors or see its poor design, or suffer with its speed, responsiveness of the interface. And programs for Windows, with all due respect, are of dubious value with hacker holes, for example, because it is easier for people to install hacked software than to buy the same Windows from the developer for 10 thousand rubles, plus a set of necessary programs. What people really pay money for is antivirus packages. And I repeat, I make BabaOS and all related services for myself, first of all, and then, well, someone will catch up well, no, no. In addition, Apple began to do bad things with its user interface; it is now very overloaded and becomes similar to the same Windows or Linux desktop. That is, you understand that there are fewer and fewer digital safe harbors in this world, while large operating systems compete with each other; the average user pays with his wallet (including his personal time) for what a priori should be accessible and free, and most importantly, convenient and comfortable for my eyes. So the point here is not only about another convenient interface, but far beyond it.
 
Jesus Christ. Another Linux refuge flooding the forums with this type of bulls**t. Why not just use vanilla FreeBSD to your liking and go on about your day.

Understand something; FreeBSD is a base operating system; a concept that is non-existent with the GNU/Linux split dichotomy. It's incredibly difficult to fork and maintain a separate, complete operating system. You will likely burn out and abandon your project.

Just use FreeBSD.
I can’t just use something from existing solutions, because it’s not convenient and expensive. I used to use it, but they are traitors, Ubuntu betrayed, Apple betrayed, Microsoft also with its toys like Windows 8 and 11 where you struggle with the operating system rather than enjoying the process. And FreeBSD in its pure form, as far as I understand, entry here is practically impossible for an ordinary person who wants to move from other inconvenient digital apartments.
 
What we have now isn't like chatgpt 2022 era. I made KMS for virtio-gpu work on arm64 in 1 day. I made rpi500+ boot natively (not UEFI that isn't supported by my model) in 1 day. Those are real results.

However the effectiveness depends on how knowledgable the person driving it is how much background they have in how things work, they must know how to direct, and what said code is doing.

That said and what I was trying to say above. Right now I don't think it matters how good it is, because what's going to happen is there will be 1 million tiny projects that get no attention no matter how much more they have to offer, because there two many people doing their own things, too many to pick from, and then there will be established projects like FreeBSD. It's just like there were always thousands of 1-person Linux distributions and only a few get significant amounts of users. I already see this happening in real time, it's kind of cool, but these cannot be FreeBSD replacements, and lets face it KDE isn't going to get overtaken either. That goes for even my hobby projects.

Established projects like FreeBSD will still get more attention of course because they have teams responsible for security fixes, they have teams in general. There is less likelihood for breaches, or data loss from a true project vs a one person project. For 1 person projects, they should be careful for that reason as well how far they go with things. The reason is just because a project is open source does not make them immune to lawsuits for data loss, breaches, or infringement. Without a foundation (which you need more than 1 person for), or an LLC (which involves spending a fair amount of time and money to establish) there is no protection at all. There is no firewall for personal assets without something like one of those in place for anyone who distributes software. A great license alone is not a 100% guarantee of no risk especially without those.
Agree.
 
This is not about the usefulness of a product, thing, person, but about its availability. You know, in order for me to buy a computer from Apple with their operating system, I need to spend at least 30 thousand rubles for hardware that costs a maximum of 15 thousand, that is, pay two and a half times for hardware that is already at least 5 years old. For this money I could build a good powerful gaming PC, or a graphics workstation, or buy a game console. But unfortunately, it is not possible for an ordinary person who does not understand computers to work with Windows or Linux; for this, you need to pay too much time to understand which distribution to choose, or how to configure Windows correctly, or suffer with its errors or see its poor design, or suffer with its speed, responsiveness of the interface. And programs for Windows, with all due respect, are of dubious value with hacker holes, for example, because it is easier for people to install hacked software than to buy the same Windows from the developer for 10 thousand rubles, plus a set of necessary programs. What people really pay money for is antivirus packages. And I repeat, I make BabaOS and all related services for myself, first of all, and then, well, someone will catch up well, no, no. In addition, Apple began to do bad things with its user interface; it is now very overloaded and becomes similar to the same Windows or Linux desktop. That is, you understand that there are fewer and fewer digital safe harbors in this world, while large operating systems compete with each other; the average user pays with his wallet (including his personal time) for what a priori should be accessible and free, and most importantly, convenient and comfortable for my eyes. So the point here is not only about another convenient interface, but far beyond it.
You are right o/c. That is why we are here after all.
I am just suspecting that your work might be in vain if UI, if not the whole OS landscape, changes thanks to for example, LLMs being able to generate the UI.
But that is uncertain and in any case for you to decide. Any new wm/desktop option is welcome. At the very least someone can learn from your work.

Time of proprietary software and software license business is hopefully over. So even hunter from Irkutsk can afford good Operating System to run pr0n on :)
 
It is a year old study. It improved quite a bit. Sure, if someone wants production ready Minecraft, that is a lot of mistakes. But people are using it and have results. Sure it is more of Ai assisted than vibecoded but I heard several dudes with active projects saying it saved them months as they can compare. But they also say, you need to assemble it by small pieces.
One problem I see reported is that people start a lot projects, they wouldn't dare to without Ai and it bogs them down eventually. Like when you rent an excabator and suddenly you can dig up the whole garden - but should you?
This is a question where the answer depends on the focus of attention, where the user is looking and whether the whole garden needs to be dug up, or whether he is happy with the state of affairs. I don't. Roughly speaking, I would like to see real progress in the age of AI and technical revolutions, and not something that you are fed with pieces from the table of large companies, year after year. That is, we don’t see a really cool OS, and if there is one, it is very, very expensive for a mere mortal, including the cost of his personal time, as is the case with Linux or BSD. I must admit that I also keep my own diary about technology and sometimes write down my thoughts about life in general. And one more thing: my OS is not only about FreeBSD, but also about web services. I’m the kind of person who wants to understand everything that’s happening, you know? For example, why do we have highly complex and sometimes outdated technologies that no one is in a hurry to develop? Every day I hear about iPhones, MacBooks, about how cool Apple is and how great it is at protecting our data and the ecology of the planet, but this does not make people happier, since not everyone is able to buy their products and make money from creativity. They should have provided all segments of society with their computers long ago, and done it at an affordable price, and not for thousands of dollars. And Windows wins here, their OS can be installed on any PC, but is it pleasant to use? Personally, I don’t, because in our age of AI, an operating system should be cool and one that impresses the user with its design and responsiveness, and not a closed garden for the elite.
 
FreeBSD in its pure form, as far as I understand, entry here is practically impossible
The greatest hurdle are drivers, tho. As it was and still is for Linux but even greater. Wm/desktop is just icing on the cake.
Then you have SW/apps. Linuxlator and of course our dear porters do some heavy lifting but still...
 
Back
Top