Good bad experiences with social media "mastodon" & "bluesky" compared to "Reddit"

It's just far too easy to get sucked in to the stupidest arguments with the worst people on the internet.
I don't mind stupid arguments.

The reason why I don't use Reddit is that the thread format makes it hard to cover everything without repetition when you visit the same topic several times. I don't have time for that.
 
For myself, I find Reddit sometimes useful when I have a specific question. Usually non tech type, like, Does anyone know the name of this film, X happened and then Y and I forget the rest. On occasion tech questions, e.g., there was a useful post on the RHCSA exam there at one point. But I usually only go there if a web search has led me there, perhaps that's why I seldom see the toxic sort of thing drhowarddrfine mentions. I guess I consider it an alternate place to look if I can't find an answer, and also useful for obscure questions, such as the one I mention above about getting a movie name.
 
I don't mind stupid arguments.

The reason why I don't use Reddit is that the thread format makes it hard to cover everything without repetition when you visit the same topic several times. I don't have time for that.
True. Reddit is good for discussing topics where there are recurrent changes, e.g. sport, AI models (they change often), songs, books, films. Also experiences in using certain evolving technologies. But for ever-green discussions on philosophical questions, it is better a traditional forum with a smaller audience, otherwise it is an annoying repetition of the same concepts. One become the BOT of him-self.
 
But I usually only go there if a web search has led me there
Same here. I have not intentionally gone there--I want to say for a decade or more--except when someone sends me a link and I didn't pay attention. One guy I know got in the habit of just copy/pasting what he wants to show me and email it to me to avoid my jumping down his throat for the link.
 
I don't have time for that.
cracauer@ I remember the last time I went there I got sucked into one of those things where someone wrote something obviously wrong about FreeBSD. I made a minor comment to correct him along with a link to the documentation. He continued to argue I was wrong while others commented about my mental condition and continued downvoting into oblivion while other jumped all up and down about how they aren't FreeBSD users and that the problem was the reason they never use FreeBSD while posting on the FreeBSD sub. And that wasn't the first time but it was definitely my last.
 
I totally disagree with everything said here.

Look at the SDR reddit.

Does that look like uninformed people?
Certain topics shine there some do not.
Sure, there has to be some good stuff on there somewhere. It's just a platform at the end of the day. I don't usually bother with it just because other sites (like this forum) are generally much better. And there does seem to be a lot of noise in many of the discussions on reddit.
 
Just for interest, does anyone still use ... irc? Or usenet?

... the big chicken...
That's "Foghorn Leghorn" 😄 . Whoever thought this stuff up was brilliant!
1785250631798.png
 
I try to use irc, but it's greatly changed. For example, #freebsd will have a few hundred people there, but no conversation. Sometimes if you ask a question you get an answer, but often you don't.
I've also found that the #weeslack channel will sometimes be helpful if there's an issue, but other times, I got no answers till I opened an issue on their github. (weeslack enables you to use slack with weechat) https://github.com/wee-slack/wee-slack

I don't think I've visited too many others in awhile. I said this in another thread about irc, but #freebsd used to be a hangout, lots of us exchanging information and helping people, conversation always going on in channel and privately. I guess this was in the mid double oughts.

I know a guy who still relies on it for much of his information seeking. I believe he mainly uses Gentoo. I remember, again years ago, that channel was always busy and there was even a #gentoo-buffy, because a lot gentoo users were buffy fans and the mods got annoyed at too much off topic conversation.

TL;DR yeah, I still use irc sometimes, but there seems to be far less socializing there than there used to be.
 
Scammers post on LinkedIn / Indeed / Monster and rarely (if ever) get called for it. Victims of the said scams post reactions on Reddit. You wanna be informed on how to see through a scam and stay out of trouble, read both places. Virtually everyone who posts on LinkedIn is too busy / too cool / too smart to pay attention to Reddit. Just the more obvious example of the Great Digital Divide.

cracauer@ I remember the last time I went there I got sucked into one of those things where someone wrote something obviously wrong about FreeBSD. I made a minor comment to correct him along with a link to the documentation. He continued to argue I was wrong while others commented about my mental condition and continued downvoting into oblivion while other jumped all up and down about how they aren't FreeBSD users and that the problem was the reason they never use FreeBSD while posting on the FreeBSD sub. And that wasn't the first time but it was definitely my last.
Yeah, that was basically my problem with Discord - someone wanted to talk about political issues totally unrelated to FreeBSD - while using the FreeBSD Discord server for that. I tried to call the guy out on that - and got banned by a mod who was personal friends with the kid. Happened over a year ago. I am under impression that the kid never really understood the extent to which his agenda was out of place specifically on the FreeBSD Discord server.
 
I try to use irc, but it's greatly changed. For example, #freebsd will have a few hundred people there, but no conversation. Sometimes if you ask a question you get an answer, but often you don't.
I've also found that the #weeslack channel will sometimes be helpful if there's an issue, but other times, I got no answers till I opened an issue on their github. (weeslack enables you to use slack with weechat) https://github.com/wee-slack/wee-slack

I don't think I've visited too many others in awhile. I said this in another thread about irc, but #freebsd used to be a hangout, lots of us exchanging information and helping people, conversation always going on in channel and privately. I guess this was in the mid double oughts.

I know a guy who still relies on it for much of his information seeking. I believe he mainly uses Gentoo. I remember, again years ago, that channel was always busy and there was even a #gentoo-buffy, because a lot gentoo users were buffy fans and the mods got annoyed at too much off topic conversation.

TL;DR yeah, I still use irc sometimes, but there seems to be far less socializing there than there used to be.
I am using irc and I asked on #freebsd few times and got the answer very fast. But as you said the irc is not the same as was 40 years ago :).
 
Scammers post on LinkedIn / Indeed / Monster and rarely (if ever) get called for it. Victims of the said scams post reactions on Reddit. You wanna be informed on how to see through a scam and stay out of trouble, read both places. Virtually everyone who posts on LinkedIn is too busy / too cool / too smart to pay attention to Reddit. Just the more obvious example of the Great Digital Divide.
Linkedin is another one I never bother with. I thought monster and indeed were just job adverts.
 
For the skeptical, show me the noise / stupid posts,
A better example can be this Reddit homelab community. It is full of examples, from the crazies one, to the inspiring and professionally done. Despite having 536K weekly visitors and ~ 10K weekly messages it is surprisingly a "nice place". Probably also because for each new post, there must be some real work done.

Obviously, it is a Reddit forum. So, if one want professional material to study, there are other better sources. But for a fun exchange of information, it is a good place.

Mastodon is more for showing "the news", but discussions tend to be polarized and/or toxic. Reddit for proposing new material and quickly discussing it. Other chats/forum with smaller communities are probably better for long-term discussions. But in Reddit, what you wrote today, is lost after few time, because there are too much users. So, they are ephemeral discussions.

Disclaimer: all of this IMHO.
 
Back
Top