Reactions were sharply divided between awe at AI-assisted engineering velocity and skepticism from seasoned toolmakers:
- The Optimists: Seeing seven native Rust creative tools appear overnight without telemetry or monthly subscriptions felt like an open-source triumph against Adobe’s corporate rent-seeking.
- The Pragmatists: Power users immediately tested realistic workflows and encountered the classic Ninety-Ninety Rule of software engineering (the first 90% of the code accounts for the first 90% of development time; the remaining 10% takes the other 90%). Japanese designer @fujix noted that PhotoCraft completely failed to accept Japanese text input, and canvas panning stuttered under complex layout PSDs.
To the author’s credit, the repository openly admits that “vibe-coding” initial architecture creates shallow coverage: early alpha testers discovered 214 keyboard shortcut failures, offset text carets, and sticky crop handles that naive unit tests had missed. Wiring 626 menus with an LLM is fast; perfecting thirty years of human motor interaction requires patient, disciplined engineering.