ZFS and different disks

M

Migelo

Hi!

Currently I have HTPC configured like this;
HW:
  • AMD Athlon II x2 260
  • GIGABYTE GA-M68M-SP2
  • 4GB DDR2 800MHz RAM
  • 1xWD 500GB 7.2k
  • 3xWD Green 2TB in RAID5

Now, I'm upgrading. I'll be running FreeBSD with Buying 3 new disks , but which one?

For convenience's sake, let's say, I have these on my disposal:
http://www.hoh.de/hardware/festplat...14-2000gb-3-5-sata-6gb/s-7200rpm-64mb?c=30090

http://www.hoh.de/hardware/festplat...5k3000-2000gb-sata-6gb/s-5400rpm-32mb?c=30090

http://www.hoh.de/hardware/festplat...d-caviar-green-2000gb-sata-i6gb/s-3.5?c=30090

Which one? The specifications say that Seagate has only 2400 power on hours / year specified, can't find data for other disks though. I only know that the WD Green are hated by a lot of people and software for their aggressive head parking and lacking-TLER support.
How does ZFS deal with combining different disks?
 
@Migelo

ZFS doesn´t care what disks you have, at all:)

So you can mix-match whatever you want. TLER is not required, but still a nice feature to have. What is does is that when ZFS recieves a request about IO that should be read/written, if the underlying drive is damaged and can´t accomodate that, the drive can come back early to say, "I couldn´t". Without that, ZFS has to wait for another instance to reply, e.g. controller/driver to reply in a similar manner, and if they don´t, ZFS continues to wait, and wait, and wait...

/Sebulon
 
AFAIK the only thing that is really required is that the disks and disk controllers do not lie about when the data has been really persisted (e.g. reached the platters, or a non-volatile battery backed cache memory), because ZFS depend on that for data consistency. So it helps to keep the logic between ZFS and the drives as simple as possible, I tend to only use disks on 'dumb' HBA's.

But that's not even ZFS specific.. if the storage system lies about cache flushes you're basically walking the edge of a cliff with any file system :P
 
Ok, thanks!

So which controller would you suggest? Does the IBM ServeRaid M1015 really work amazing with FreeBSD?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top