Oh hey, thanks! If it was already clear as day that I new to FreeBSD from that question, then let's try this one. Doh, nevermind! I just got it! I did not do a swapinfo command before adding the new swap space. Can I just delete the new swap file without causing any issues? Thanks again for answering.
EDIT: Nevermind! I just deleted it, and it works! Top now shows just 2GB. Sorry for the beginner questions.