Sorry to revive an old thread but I am returning to FreeBSD after using Linux and again getting pee'd off with it.
I came across the same issues as before and found the previous help from Jose, this time I asked Ai to help.
I am enclosing the whole chat to serve as a reminder to myself and assist anyone else who maybe interested.
I am actually making good progress in freebsd and currently updating approx 50 or so old bash scripts by changing convert to magick for imagemagick 7. Now if it were Linux I would use one of two tools / commands to save my work as a backup botcd with bootcdwrite to backup the complete system, or mksqshfs to backup the root directory. This appears to be more challenging with freebsd, do you know of a tool that will do same or can you create one for me?
Converting ~50 legacy Bash scripts from convert (ImageMagick 6) to magick (ImageMagick 7) is a serious undertaking! That is exactly the kind of workflow progress you want to freeze in time.
The reason you are running into a wall comparing this to Linux is because FreeBSD approaches system architecture and layout differently. Because your system was auto-installed using ZFS,
you do not need a complex third-party backup tool like bootcd or to mess around trying to build a SquashFS loop image.
On FreeBSD + ZFS, you already have the most powerful, atomic, native backup and recovery system in existence built right into your core kernel.
Here is how to replicate both of your Linux workflows natively on FreeBSD, followed by an automated shell script to do the work for you.
1. The
Under Linux, mksquashfs creates a highly compressed, read-only filesystem file that you can mount, or extract later.
On FreeBSD, rather than introducing the complexity of loops and SquashFS, the standard, native way to "freeze" your current OS state is a
ZFS Snapshot. It is instant, atomic, and takes up zero initial space.
- To take an atomic snapshot of your running system root:
Bash
sudo zfs snapshot -r zroot@my_stable_imagemagick7_system<br>
(The -r recursively snapshots your entire OS structure instantly).
- How to browse files inside this backup:You don't need to mount anything! ZFS exposes hidden directories. Just change directory to view your files exactly as they were at the second you took the snapshot:
Bash
<span>cd</span> /home/.zfs/snapshot/my_stable_imagemagick7_system/<br>
- To rollback if a script edit breaks the OS:
Bash
sudo zfs rollback -r zroot/ROOT/default@my_stable_imagemagick7_system<br>
2. The
Under Linux, bootcd clones your live OS to an ISO/USB. On FreeBSD, you can replicate this by writing a compressed
ZFS Replication Stream directly to a file on your external storage (like your USB or secondary disk).
If your main drive completely dies, you can boot
any standard FreeBSD installer USB, import this stream file, and walk away with an identical, perfectly bootable clone of your system.
- To save your entire running OS to a single backup file on your external drive:
Bash
sudo zfs send -R zroot@my_stable_imagemagick7_system > /mntpt/freebsd_backup.zfs<br>
(This exports your entire operating system—including the boot sectors, system settings, desktop environment, and Python installations—into a single file).
3. Your Custom Automated Backup Tool
To make your life easy, I have written a native FreeBSD POSIX shell script called bsd-freeze.
It will automatically:
- Generate a ZFS snapshot of your system with a timestamp.
- Let you choose to either keep it as a local rollback point (like mksquashfs) OR export it as a single-file portable stream to your mounted external drive (like bootcd).
Setup:
- Create the file:
Bash
nano /usr/<span>local</span>/bin/bsd-freeze<br>
- Paste the following script inside:
Bash
<span>#!/bin/sh</span><br><span># bsd-freeze: A native FreeBSD system imaging / backup utility</span><br><br><span>set</span> -e<br><br><span># Make sure we are root</span><br><span>if</span> [ <span>"<span>$(id -u)</span>"</span> -ne 0 ]; <span>then</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Error: This script must be run as root."</span> >&2<br> <span>exit</span> 1<br><span>fi</span><br><br>TIMESTAMP=$(date +%Y%m%d_%H%M%S)<br>SNAP_NAME=<span>"freeze_<span>${TIMESTAMP}</span>"</span><br>POOL=<span>"zroot"</span><br><br><span>echo</span> <span>"========================================="</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>" FreeBSD BSD-FREEZE Utility "</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"========================================="</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"System snapshot name: <span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>""</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"1) Create Local Snapshot (Atomic Rollback Point)"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"2) Export System Image to File (Full Portable Backup)"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"3) Exit"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"-----------------------------------------"</span><br><span>read</span> -p <span>"Select an option [1-3]: "</span> OPTION<br><br><span>case</span> <span>$OPTION</span> <span>in</span><br> 1)<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Creating recursive ZFS snapshot..."</span><br> zfs snapshot -r <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Success! Snapshot <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span> created."</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"You can browse your system state at: /home/.zfs/snapshot/<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>/"</span><br> ;;<br> 2)<br> <span>read</span> -p <span>"Enter full path to destination directory (e.g., /mntpt): "</span> DEST_DIR<br> <span>if</span> [ ! -d <span>"<span>$DEST_DIR</span>"</span> ]; <span>then</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Error: Directory <span>$DEST_DIR</span> does not exist."</span> >&2<br> <span>exit</span> 1<br> <span>fi</span><br> <br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Creating temporary system snapshot..."</span><br> zfs snapshot -r <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span><br> <br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Exporting compressed system stream to <span>${DEST_DIR}</span>/<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>.zfs..."</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"This may take several minutes depending on your storage s
I am actually making good progress in freebsd and currently updating approx 50 or so old bash scripts by changing convert to magick for imagemagick 7. Now if it were Linux I would use one of two tools / commands to save my work as a backup botcd with bootcdwrite to backup the complete system, or mksqshfs to backup the root directory. This appears to be more challenging with freebsd, do you know of a tool that will do same or can you create one for me?
Converting ~50 legacy Bash scripts from convert (ImageMagick 6) to magick (ImageMagick 7) is a serious undertaking! That is exactly the kind of workflow progress you want to freeze in time.
The reason you are running into a wall comparing this to Linux is because FreeBSD approaches system architecture and layout differently. Because your system was auto-installed using ZFS,
you do not need a complex third-party backup tool like bootcd or to mess around trying to build a SquashFS loop image.
On FreeBSD + ZFS, you already have the most powerful, atomic, native backup and recovery system in existence built right into your core kernel.
Here is how to replicate both of your Linux workflows natively on FreeBSD, followed by an automated shell script to do the work for you.
1. The
Under Linux, mksquashfs creates a highly compressed, read-only filesystem file that you can mount, or extract later.
On FreeBSD, rather than introducing the complexity of loops and SquashFS, the standard, native way to "freeze" your current OS state is a
ZFS Snapshot. It is instant, atomic, and takes up zero initial space.
- To take an atomic snapshot of your running system root:
Bash
sudo zfs snapshot -r zroot@my_stable_imagemagick7_system<br>
(The -r recursively snapshots your entire OS structure instantly).
- How to browse files inside this backup:You don't need to mount anything! ZFS exposes hidden directories. Just change directory to view your files exactly as they were at the second you took the snapshot:
Bash
<span>cd</span> /home/.zfs/snapshot/my_stable_imagemagick7_system/<br>
- To rollback if a script edit breaks the OS:
Bash
sudo zfs rollback -r zroot/ROOT/default@my_stable_imagemagick7_system<br>
2. The
Under Linux, bootcd clones your live OS to an ISO/USB. On FreeBSD, you can replicate this by writing a compressed
ZFS Replication Stream directly to a file on your external storage (like your USB or secondary disk).
If your main drive completely dies, you can boot
any standard FreeBSD installer USB, import this stream file, and walk away with an identical, perfectly bootable clone of your system.
- To save your entire running OS to a single backup file on your external drive:
Bash
sudo zfs send -R zroot@my_stable_imagemagick7_system > /mntpt/freebsd_backup.zfs<br>
(This exports your entire operating system—including the boot sectors, system settings, desktop environment, and Python installations—into a single file).
3. Your Custom Automated Backup Tool
To make your life easy, I have written a native FreeBSD POSIX shell script called bsd-freeze.
It will automatically:
- Generate a ZFS snapshot of your system with a timestamp.
- Let you choose to either keep it as a local rollback point (like mksquashfs) OR export it as a single-file portable stream to your mounted external drive (like bootcd).
Setup:
- Create the file:
Bash
nano /usr/<span>local</span>/bin/bsd-freeze<br>
- Paste the following script inside:
Bash
<span>#!/bin/sh</span><br><span># bsd-freeze: A native FreeBSD system imaging / backup utility</span><br><br><span>set</span> -e<br><br><span># Make sure we are root</span><br><span>if</span> [ <span>"<span>$(id -u)</span>"</span> -ne 0 ]; <span>then</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Error: This script must be run as root."</span> >&2<br> <span>exit</span> 1<br><span>fi</span><br><br>TIMESTAMP=$(date +%Y%m%d_%H%M%S)<br>SNAP_NAME=<span>"freeze_<span>${TIMESTAMP}</span>"</span><br>POOL=<span>"zroot"</span><br><br><span>echo</span> <span>"========================================="</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>" FreeBSD BSD-FREEZE Utility "</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"========================================="</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"System snapshot name: <span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>""</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"1) Create Local Snapshot (Atomic Rollback Point)"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"2) Export System Image to File (Full Portable Backup)"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"3) Exit"</span><br><span>echo</span> <span>"-----------------------------------------"</span><br><span>read</span> -p <span>"Select an option [1-3]: "</span> OPTION<br><br><span>case</span> <span>$OPTION</span> <span>in</span><br> 1)<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Creating recursive ZFS snapshot..."</span><br> zfs snapshot -r <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Success! Snapshot <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span> created."</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"You can browse your system state at: /home/.zfs/snapshot/<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>/"</span><br> ;;<br> 2)<br> <span>read</span> -p <span>"Enter full path to destination directory (e.g., /mntpt): "</span> DEST_DIR<br> <span>if</span> [ ! -d <span>"<span>$DEST_DIR</span>"</span> ]; <span>then</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Error: Directory <span>$DEST_DIR</span> does not exist."</span> >&2<br> <span>exit</span> 1<br> <span>fi</span><br> <br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Creating temporary system snapshot..."</span><br> zfs snapshot -r <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span><br> <br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Exporting compressed system stream to <span>${DEST_DIR}</span>/<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>.zfs..."</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"This may take several minutes depending on your storage speed..."</span><br> zfs send -R <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span> | gzip > <span>"<span>${DEST_DIR}</span>/<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>.zfs"</span><br> <br> <span># Clean up the local snapshot if we only wanted the file copy</span><br> <span>read</span> -p <span>"Keep local recovery snapshot as well? [y/N]: "</span> KEEP_LOCAL<br> <span>case</span> <span>"<span>$KEEP_LOCAL</span>"</span> <span>in</span><br> [yY][eE][sS]|[yY])<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Keeping local snapshot <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>."</span><br> ;;<br> *)<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Removing local temporary snapshot..."</span><br> zfs destroy -r <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span><br> ;;<br> <span>esac</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Process completed successfully!"</span><br> ;;<br> *)<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Exiting."</span><br> <span>exit</span> 0<br> ;;<br><span>esac</span><br>
- Make it executable:
Bash
chmod +x /usr/<span>local</span>/bin/bsd-freeze<br>
Now, whenever you finish a batch of script edits and want to lock in your progress, just run:
Bash
sudo bsd-freeze<br>
It will instantly freeze your FreeBSD workspace exactly how you left it!
peed..."</span><br> zfs send -R <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span> | gzip > <span>"<span>${DEST_DIR}</span>/<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>.zfs"</span><br> <br> <span># Clean up the local snapshot if we only wanted the file copy</span><br> <span>read</span> -p <span>"Keep local recovery snapshot as well? [y/N]: "</span> KEEP_LOCAL<br> <span>case</span> <span>"<span>$KEEP_LOCAL</span>"</span> <span>in</span><br> [yY][eE][sS]|[yY])<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Keeping local snapshot <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span>."</span><br> ;;<br> *)<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Removing local temporary snapshot..."</span><br> zfs destroy -r <span>${POOL}</span>@<span>${SNAP_NAME}</span><br> ;;<br> <span>esac</span><br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Process completed successfully!"</span><br> ;;<br> *)<br> <span>echo</span> <span>"Exiting."</span><br> <span>exit</span> 0<br> ;;<br><span>esac</span><br>
- Make it executable:
Bash
chmod +x /usr/<span>local</span>/bin/bsd-freeze<br>
Now, whenever you finish a batch of script edits and want to lock in your progress, just run:
Bash
sudo bsd-freeze<br>
It will instantly freeze your FreeBSD workspace exactly how you left it!