Knobs vs. options?

D

Daniel Tourde

Hello,

I am giving FreeBSD (10.2) a try. I am a Gentoo Linux user, pretty comfortable with portage. The FreeBSD port system is not easy for me.
First of all: what is the difference between a knob and an option?
I noticed that ports-mgmt/lsknobs and a look at the Makefile does not give me the same information.
 
Generally, options are what is shown by the menus presented when building a port. Knobs are variables, generally set on the command line. For example, emulators/virtualbox has many selectable options. lsknobs shows that there is also a "knob" called WITH_OPENSSL_BASE.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand the difference between the 2 mechanisms. Why two ways of configuring a package instead of one? What is the fundamental difference?
 
Knobs are rarely-changed settings, for advanced users or special cases. If they were for general use, they would be options.

Oh, and in general we recommend accepting the defaults unless you are certain that an option should be changed.
 
wblock@ said:
...in general we recommend accepting the defaults unless you are certain that an option should be changed.
Click to expand...
wblock@, did you intend to say option or knob?

I almost never change knobs, but I change options all the time. Of course, it makes sense to only change an option for a good reason, but there are often good reasons. For example, simply turning off the dbus option in www/firefox means many fewer packages will be installed that serve no purpose if you aren't running a desktop environment. This level of control is something missing from all other operating systems (that I'm aware of). Without them, we might as well just exclusively use packages like most GNU/Linux distributions.
 
It really doesn't matter, it applies to both options and knobs, but yes, I did mean option. It is fine to change an option when you understand what it means. But we sometimes see newcomers who end up with non-functioning applications after taking a heavy hand to incompletely-understood options.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top