Hey we made the news...

I dont think On the foolishness of "natural language programming" by Dijkstra is a gatekeeper, it is just how solving problems is, it is always better to have a specific meaning condensed to a symbol, sure it is difficult to learn, but it pays off.

I still think that at better prompting even in loops is becoming a PM, never a programmer, because in fact you dont program anymore. Yeah, you can use prompts to write code I did for an elixir app wich worked, but I didnt learn anything really about elixir... and I have learn probably more than 10 or 20 or 30 programming languages in my life, but sure I didnt learn a thing when I used the LLM, as any PM doesnt become a programmer just because s/he can talk with you about a feature to develop.

Why people want to use LLMs to do freebsd or any other operative system you want more output like for example check https://github.com/LiberNT/LiberNT which in some months is at least 2x or 3x than the most prominent commiter in reactos in a lot of years of effort. Do people want free bsd or any bsd become libernt really? (also why not just do a fork and code all with claude or watever from now on like he and be X times more productive?).




What would be the purpose of allowing LLMs? just use the tokens you dont have any use of? finally being able to contribute code (I want to contribute too, but I will take the long path and ask humans and maybe some day send a PR by hand, instead of ask the LLM to let me do it in a few hours... maybe jsut read some summaries or ask about things I dont want to botter people here on the forum or on discord...).

If you thought the speed of writing code was your problem - you have bigger problems I link this with Braess's paradox when you think you are solving a hicup but instead you are not solving the actual issue at hand. As the article says... what value are you trying to add allowing llms?

* just using the new thing?
* burn tokens?
* contribute by sending various PRs?
* want to actually learn the internals? (zig doesnt allow llm code as they want the language also be used as a learning plataform for people that can handle that level of complexity).

I also find curious that in the original article it says that they want to add documentation with LLMs... why not all just join a hackathon a weekend and do some actual contribution as a community? why being lazy and not organized at all??? why use the tool when you have the oportunity to make community... or this community doesnt care about inviting people to do "trivial" task of write documentation?

I remember a documentathon on a library I used some years a go, it got almost all covered in some days, maybe some weeks.... not sure how much that documentation helped people later.
 
I dont think On the foolishness of "natural language programming" by Dijkstra is a gatekeeper, it is just how solving problems is, it is always better to have a specific meaning condensed to a symbol, sure it is difficult to learn, but it pays off.

I still think that at better prompting even in loops is becoming a PM, never a programmer, because in fact you dont program anymore. Yeah, you can use prompts to write code I did for an elixir app wich worked, but I didnt learn anything really about elixir... and I have learn probably more than 10 or 20 or 30 programming languages in my life, but sure I didnt learn a thing when I used the LLM, as any PM doesnt become a programmer just because s/he can talk with you about a feature to develop.
Prompts and specs are not about using natural language for programming, but about translating ideas into existing programming languages. It can be done, it should be done.

I no longer need to learn an ugly programming language like Rust to get stuff done. It's a win-win. I don't miss it at all.
 
Computing has failed mankind for so many decades
true. Reason being (among others, sure) named by Dijkstra (nobody got fired buying IBM), Wirth (a plea for lean software) and Eric Evans (Tech people don't care about domains): exploding complexity. More often than not for rounded corners, gradients and animations. And computing got away with it.

Time for frugality and sufficiency, if computing doesn't want to fail the planet as well as just mankind.

"The Power to serve" would be a fitting claim.
 
true. Reason being (among others, sure) named by Dijkstra (nobody got fired buying IBM), Wirth (a plea for lean software) and Eric Evans (Tech people don't care about domains): exploding complexity. More often than not for rounded corners, gradients and animations. And computing got away with it.

We can't escape complexity. We live in a complex world and we invented machines to handle it. We failed when we added more complexity than we can handle instead of decreasing it.

Time for frugality and sufficiency, if computing doesn't want to fail the planet as well as just mankind.

I no longer believe in climate hysteria as it's a secular doomsday cult to me. Achieving net zero is completely unrealistic and it would cost bllions just to decrease a fraction of a Celsius degree. The green agenda has also been hijacked by politicians to implement so-called "climate justice" to redistribute wealth from the poor in rich countries to the rich in poor countries. It's a huge waste of money that would push billions of people to populisms on both the left & right. Degrowth is just madness.

I no longer fear their "worst-case scenarios". We either implement technological solutions or deserve or even embrace what's gonna happen. I'll be recompiling UNIX kernels & running `make buildworld && make installworld` anyway.
 
Hi rbranco,
with due respect, physics isn't a matter of belief, measurements aren't opinions. The biosphere depletes. I don't talk about projections, it's now. Do everybody what seems fit.

Degrowth is just madness.
show me anything that grows forever. Do you?

I'd prefer the pulsing dynamics of nature (e.g. the tides) over growth+collapse scenarios every day. The collapse often is wars. I don't like them.
 
Hi rbranco,
with due respect, physics isn't a matter of belief, measurements aren't opinions. The biosphere depletes. I don't talk about projections, it's now. Do everybody what seems fit.


show me anything that grows forever. Do you?

I'd prefer the pulsing dynamics of nature (e.g. the tides) over growth+collapse scenarios every day. The collapse often is wars. I don't like them.
Let's put aside that the measurements are mostly insufficient to make the climate models predict the scenarios correctly.
Let's put aside the political agendas....to cripple the West.

Everything grows all the time. Or it dies. Iron rusts, you need to exchange it and for that you need power.

And we need to grow pretty big to avoid the inevitable doom of our whole solar system, let alone the Mother Earth.

Sure, burning fossil fuels is dirty business. But we won't find something better to use burning bee wax candles every other night.
And what gets me is, we already found better source of energy. Somehow the "environmentalists" are opposing it hard.
 
Ok, show me eternal organic growth then. Without intermittent deaths, naturally. The state mandated and 5-year plans are yours, I didn't bring them.
 
Ok, show me eternal organic growth then. Without intermittent deaths, naturally. The state mandated and 5-year plans are yours, I didn't bring them.
Eternal organic growth is impossible. I reject both artificial growth & state-mandated degrowth. Mao introduced a time bomb in his own country with the one-child policy.
 
Hi rbranco,
with due respect, physics isn't a matter of belief, measurements aren't opinions. The biosphere depletes. I don't talk about projections, it's now. Do everybody what seems fit.

Blaming mankind for Klimakatastrophe has been a way to blame Capitalism so they can recommend third-world Socialism.

The only way to solve problems is to come up with realistic solutions, and the so-called "green" parties that pushed for shutting down nuclear power are not part of it.
 
Artificial intelligence is definitely a hot topic these days.

For example, if a programmer needs to translate a software application into 100 languages, do you really think companies are going to hire 100 linguists?

I'm from Ukraine, and we have some funny screenshots of Windows 98 translations. How would you translate something like: "105-key keyboard — press Enter with your foot"?

I think people should simply be honest about what they're actually skilled at and where they've used outside assistance.

In the past, programmers used Stack Overflow to ask questions whenever they encountered an error. Someone would post a solution, the programmer would copy the code, make it work, and nobody had a problem with that. Nobody questioned their qualifications.

But now we have LLMs, neural networks, and code generators, and suddenly it's considered unacceptable?

There is technical documentation written in formal academic English, often with excellent explanations and simple examples. Yet sometimes AI does a better job of breaking down complicated terminology and explaining what the author actually means.

Believe me, sometimes you read a Ukrainian translation and wonder what on earth something like a "linear trimmer" is supposed to mean. We have plenty of technical slang and informal expressions that don't translate literally.

I know a programmer who used to hire people from India to complete individual programming tasks for $5 each. Whoever could solve the problem got paid. Nobody judged him for it.

But suddenly AI appears, and now everyone is concerned about what to do with programmers!

Meanwhile, nobody seems to mention that even before AI, plenty of people called themselves programmers without necessarily having the skills to back it up — and they were getting paid for it.

And seriously, are we now expected to know C/C++, Java, Python, PHP, Swift, and who knows how many other languages, not to mention all the tools and utilities involved in software development?

At this rate, I suppose I should start teaching my children programming from the moment they're born, because employers already seem to demand at least ten years of experience!
 
Blaming mankind for Klimakatastrophe has been a way to blame Capitalism so they can recommend third-world Socialism.

The only way to solve problems is to come up with realistic solutions, and the so-called "green" parties that pushed for shutting down nuclear power are not part of it.
And it is not even about the environment. It is about power and control as always.
To create the conditions i.e. the ruin, in order to take power. The same revolutionary blueprint.

Everyone remembers or should, how the environment looked under Socialism. It was horrible. Our rivers were toxic. People care only when it is their property (to protect it or not to pay fines for damaging other's), otherwise it is the so called tragedy of the commons.

I don't even blame the environmentalist socialist useful fools.
Behind every little socialist environmentalist there is big NeoFeudal Kalergist waiting to assume throne....to hunt deer while peasants eat slop.
 
In general open source projects shouldn't, and definitely not before the laws are updated to consider the lack of license that you get when generating code that's been trained on whoever knows whose code.

I think AIs are potentially fine as a way of finding things to fix, but when it comes to actually fixing them, we don't need another lawsuit threatening to shutdown entire projects due to code slipping in from another project without the appropriate licensing.


I think that is more important that we want to use it because it is there and we can use it.


Sorry missed my main point here while editing: I think this is the most important thing to consider, the legality, it seems that the code generated by LLM is not copyrigtable, so it cant be protected by GPL, or bsd or maybe any license?? (looking at you AGPL!!!), which part of what you write is, so the code may be under the license, but because it was not authored by a human copyright doesnt hold so the license dosent hold.


Seems as code generated by LLMs is not copyrigtable, but with BSD (will be probably no friction at all if MIT license) probably there is no conflict like with GPL that requires the code be copyrigtable to be protected by GPL, still I will suguest listen andrew kelly on why llm contributions are not allowed at all about 5m@2x and maybe contributor poker

But now we have LLMs, neural networks, and code generators, and suddenly it's considered unacceptable?

with SO you read the code and worked with it, learned something, it was kind of short code a human wrote. That output with an LLM can be a complete feature, not a single bug or block you have.

Did you review all the 100x output or just doom scrolled it? did you really learn something? also reviewing for other people will be by hand (what value is expected from AI???).

If you people want full IA, the code is bsd, like I pointed above with https://github.com/LiberNT/LiberNT you can fork the code and start contributing with pure AI, even without a human in the loop and start coding, right now, without freebsd to define something for you as you want to do it... like the phrase says "just do it", that fork in some months ahve 3x the output of the top contributor of reactos in just few months, not years!!!! wonderfull isnt?.

If you want a closer one look at daemonarchy... why freebsd needs to adopt something you can do on your own? what is really the purpose to adopt llms? what is the purpose in your company to adopt llms?
 
Using Stack Overflow does not guarantee that a programmer actually understood the code they copied. Likewise, using an LLM does not mean that a programmer failed to understand the code.

Even code taken from Stack Overflow or any other programming forum needs to be analyzed and reviewed, regardless of who wrote it — a human or an AI.

AI can be used as an assistant and a tool, rather than something that does absolutely everything for you.

It's not supposed to work like in a fairy tale, where you simply say, "By magic, at my command, write me some Python code..." and expect everything to be done for you.
Using Stack Overflow does not guarantee that a programmer actually understood the code they copied. Likewise, using an LLM does not mean that a programmer failed to understand the code. Even code taken from Stack Overflow or any other programming forum needs to be analyzed and reviewed, regardless of who wrote it — a human or an AI.
AI can be used as an **assistant and a tool**, rather than something that does absolutely everything for you.
It's not supposed to work like in a fairy tale, where you simply say, "By magic, at my command, write me some Python code..." and expect everything to be done for you.
 
I think that is more important that we want to use it because it is there and we can use it.
The parts of programming that make sense to automate have largely either already been automated or are too hard to reliable automate. People are inherently kind of lazy, but using programming tools like this allows you to avoid all the actual work that it takes to properly understand what the LLM is outputting.

For personal projects people can do what they like, but the licensing issues alone are significant enough that projects shouldn't be accepting the contributions. At least with the bug issues, you can pick through it to see if there's a real issue.
 
I no longer believe in climate hysteria as it's a secular doomsday cult to me. Achieving net zero is completely unrealistic and it would cost bllions just to decrease a fraction of a Celsius degree. The green agenda has also been hijacked by politicians to implement so-called "climate justice" to redistribute wealth from the poor in rich countries to the rich in poor countries. It's a huge waste of money that would push billions of people to populisms on both the left & right. Degrowth is just madness.
I know we can't meet the targets for lowering carbon emissions, but that doesn't mean we are in for a bad time with extreme weather. We could try to meet those targets, even if it's by a later date and attempt to limit damage. And electrification doesn't make you lose money. Last year, Tesla made $4 billion before taxes.
Everyone remembers or should, how the environment looked under Socialism. It was horrible. Our rivers were toxic. People care only when it is their property (to protect it or not to pay fines for damaging other's), otherwise it is the so called tragedy of the commons.
What socialism are you talking about? Assuming you are in the US, the US has never been under control of socialists. The Democrats are not socialists. Socialism means there would be government or collective control of industry. How many companies did the democrats nationalize? None in recent memory. The DSA don't count either because they are very small: 130k members vs the Democrat's 44.4m and the Republican's 37.9m. Winning a mayorship, even in new york, doesn't mean you run the country. According to their official platform, they advocate a phase-out of fossil fuels. What's the most polluting energy source? Coal, a fossil fuel.
 
Back
Top