Solved GELI - wrong key for disk

D

Deleted member 70846

Guest
Hello,

I've set up a ZFS pool, with each partition in it (da0p1 through da3p1) being encrypted with GELI.
(I know ZFS has it's own thing for encryption, but for an unrelated reason I won't use that for this pool.)
When I try to attach the disks at startup by including the following in rc.conf()...
Code: 
zfs_enable="YES"

geli_devices="da0p1 da1p1 da2p1 da3p1"

geli_da0p1_keyfile_load="YES"
geli_da0p1_keyfile_type="da0p1:geli_keyfile"
geli_da0p1_keyfile_name="/root/geli/da0p1.key"

geli_da1p1_keyfile_load="YES"
geli_da1p1_keyfile_type="da1p1:geli_keyfile"
geli_da1p1_keyfile_name="/root/geli/da1p1.key"

geli_da2p1_keyfile_load="YES"
geli_da2p1_keyfile_type="da2p1:geli_keyfile"
geli_da2p1_keyfile_name="/root/geli/da2p1.key"

geli_da3p1_keyfile_load="YES"
geli_da3p1_keyfile_type="da3p1:geli_keyfile"
geli_da3p1_keyfile_name="/root/geli/da3p1.key"

... It prompts me with the following at startup:
Code: 
Configuring Disk Encryption for da0p1.
Enter passphrase:
geli: Wrong key for da0p1.

Despite entering the correct passphrase. Note that I'm able to run something like geli attach -k /root/geli/da0p1.key /dev/da0p1 just fine, and it's instantly added to the pool. It's only when I try and attach it at startup that it's using the "wrong" key, so it must be something wrong with what I've put in rc.conf .

I've also seen some solutions on this forum using a numbered keyfile (e.g. geli_da0p1_keyfile0_type="da0p1:geli_keyfile0"), but no matter what number I'd use for that, it throws the same error.

here's the output of uname -a :
Code: 
FreeBSD $HOST 12.3-RELEASE FreeBSD 12.3-RELEASE r371126 GENERIC  amd64
 
Could that be a keymap issue? What keymap do you use?
 
The examples in the man page don't reuse the same keyfile type name, so I think you are thinking in the right direction:

Code: 
geli_da0_keyfile0_load="YES"
geli_da0_keyfile0_type="da0:geli_keyfile0"
geli_da0_keyfile0_name="/boot/keys/da0.key0"
geli_da0_keyfile1_load="YES"
geli_da0_keyfile1_type="da0:geli_keyfile1"
geli_da0_keyfile1_name="/boot/keys/da0.key1"
geli_da0_keyfile2_load="YES"
geli_da0_keyfile2_type="da0:geli_keyfile2"
geli_da0_keyfile2_name="/boot/keys/da0.key2"

i.e. maybe because you've got geli_keyfile used 3 times it won't work?
 
My point is that you need the same keymap loaded when you deal with the passwords. Setting these words with a greek keyboard layout and then typing them with a gaelic one, to be extreme here, will almost cwrtainly end up with wrong passphrases.
 
There are two ways to attach the geli(8) providers containing the ZFS pool during the boot process by keyfile automatically provided by the system:

1. From /boot/loader.conf, as described in the manual, before the root filesystem is mounted:
Code: 
/boot/loader.conf:

           geli_da0_keyfile0_load="YES"
           geli_da0_keyfile0_type="da0:geli_keyfile0"
           geli_da0_keyfile0_name="/boot/keys/da0.key0"
           geli_da0_keyfile1_load="YES"
           geli_da0_keyfile1_type="da0:geli_keyfile1"
           geli_da0_keyfile1_name="/boot/keys/da0.key1"
           geli_da0_keyfile2_load="YES"
           geli_da0_keyfile2_type="da0:geli_keyfile2"
           geli_da0_keyfile2_name="/boot/keys/da0.key2"

2. After the root file system is mounted, from /etc/rc.conf, as described in /etc/defaults/rc.conf:
Code: 
# GELI disk encryption configuration.
geli_devices=""         # List of devices to automatically attach in addition to
                        # GELI devices listed in /etc/fstab.
geli_groups=""          # List of groups containing devices to automatically
                        # attach with the same keyfiles and passphrase
geli_tries=""           # Number of times to attempt attaching geli device.
                        # If empty, kern.geom.eli.tries will be used.
geli_default_flags=""   # Default flags for geli(8).
geli_autodetach="YES"   # Automatically detach on last close.
                        # Providers are marked as such when all file systems are
                        # mounted.
# Example use.
#geli_devices="da1 mirror/home"
#geli_da1_flags="-p -k /etc/geli/da1.keys"
#geli_da1_autodetach="NO"
#geli_mirror_home_flags="-k /etc/geli/home.keys"
#geli_groups="storage backup"
#geli_storage_flags="-k /etc/geli/storage.keys"
#geli_storage_devices="ada0 ada1"
#geli_backup_flags="-j /etc/geli/backup.passfile -k /etc/geli/backup.keys"
#geli_backup_devices="ada2 ada3"

dra said:
... It prompts me with the following at startup:
Code: 
 Configuring Disk Encryption for da0p1.
Enter passphrase:
geli: Wrong key for da0p1.

Despite entering the correct passphrase. Note that I'm able to run something like geli attach -k /root/geli/da0p1.key /dev/da0p1 just fine, and it's instantly added to the pool. It's only when I try and attach it at startup that it's using the "wrong" key, so it must be something wrong with what I've put in rc.conf .
Click to expand...
As covacat already mentioned, the keyfile_{load,type,name} belongs in /boot/loader.conf, it has no effect from /etc/rc.conf.

I would use the /etc/rc.conf configuration. It's easier to configure. I assume the ZFS pools providers are attached by keyfile and passphrase:
Code: 
geli_devices="da0p1 da1p1 da2p1 da3p1"
geli_da0p1_flags="-k /root/geli/da0p1.key"
geli_da1p1_flags="-k /root/geli/da1p1.key"
etc

Also, backup the keyfiles and metadata of the providers on different external devices (i.e. quality USB sticks).
 
Crivens said:
My point is that you need the same keymap loaded when you deal with the passwords. Setting these words with a greek keyboard layout and then typing them with a gaelic one, to be extreme here, will almost cwrtainly end up with wrong passphrases.
Click to expand...
As far as I can tell, the correct keymap is loaded. I've seen other solutions for this problem involving troubleshooting the keymap, though, so I double-checked to be sure.
 
T-Daemon said:
[...]

I would use the /etc/rc.conf configuration. It's easier to configure. I assume the ZFS pools providers are attached by keyfile and passphrase:
Code: 
geli_devices="da0p1 da1p1 da2p1 da3p1"
geli_da0p1_flags="-k /root/geli/da0p1.key"
geli_da1p1_flags="-k /root/geli/da1p1.key"
etc

Also, backup the keyfiles and metadata of the providers on different external devices (i.e. quality USB sticks).
Click to expand...
Using geli_<disk>_flags in my rc.conf fixed it! Here's the current arrangement:

Code: 
geli_devices="da0p1 da1p1 da2p1 da3p1"
geli_da0p1_flags="-k /etc/geli/da0p1.key"
geli_da1p1_flags="-k /etc/geli/da1p1.key"
geli_da2p1_flags="-k /etc/geli/da2p1.key"
geli_da3p1_flags="-k /etc/geli/da3p1.key"

Problem solved! I am now able to attach the disks at startup. Thanks, everyone!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top